| |
There is a growing discontent among serious executives who have joined part-time management programmes in some prominent private business schools.
Many of them say they feel cheated as there is a big gap between the profile of the class that B-schools promise in the prospectus and what it actually turns out to be.
I don’t blame these working executives. They are being victimized by a new phenomenon that appears to be catching on in private B-schools: filling part-time Postgraduate Diploma in Management, or PGDM, courses with lots of fresh graduates.
For B-schools, especially in metros, India’s business schools regulator, the All India Council For Technical Education, or AICTE, typically sanctions seats for the part-time programme when the infrastructure—class rooms, computers—is being underutilized in the evenings or on weekends.
This is meant for executives who attend classes after finishing their office work. And, when a working executive seeks admission for a part-time programme, there are some expectations besides getting a degree. One of the most important tends to be that the peer group would consist of other “students” holding responsible positions in companies. The idea being that, besides the normal networking, this kind of group also helps in the learning process of these part-time management students.
Examining cases or doing projects in a team is a norm at B-schools. If team members are of similar intellectual level and with work experience, they can obviously relate much more easily to one another and, as a result, each participant in the class gains from the synergy.
The maturity level of such class discussions also tends to be a different plane. While there is a mix of experience and students fresh out of graduate programmes in the daytime business programmes as well, the skew is clearly towards fresh graduates and so are expectations of both teachers and students alike.
B-schools conducting part-time programmes are well aware of the desired profile of the students in such courses. Consider how the prospectus of a well known B-school in Delhi clearly specifies the profile of prospective students: “The three-year, part-time postgraduate diploma in management (PGDM) programme is meant for young individuals who are working as middle/junior level executives/officers in public or private sector organizations, but have not had an opportunity to acquire formal management education.”
But, this very school is pushing fresh graduates into this part-time programme.
An executive I know signed up for this school’s programme a few months ago. He was shocked to then discover that about 70% of the class consisted of fresh graduates. And, even among those who were supposed to be working, there were property dealers or retailers who said they were “helping” their fathers in the business. Since he had already paid the hefty first instalment of fee for the programme, this executive was trapped.
This executive isn’t alone. Many students in other private B-schools are similarly trapped as it is not mandatory for a school to disclose the profile of all the students admitted/short-listed before collecting the first instalment of fee. And B-schools can get away with such irresponsible behaviour as there is no real tradition of students taking such institutes to, say a consumer court. (The AICTE did say earlier this month that students can ask for a refund of fee, after a deduction of processing fee of not more than Rs1,000, in case the student withdraws before the beginning of the programme and a proportional refund if a student leaves the college after joining the course, though it is subject to the vacancy being filled by another candidate.)
More : livemint.com
|
Have a Question? Ask Us..
MBA students likelier to cheat
MBA students in Canada and the United States are more likely to cheat than students in other disciplines because they believe it is how the business world operates — and because they believe their peers cheat, according to a new study.
The study found that 56 per cent of graduate business students admitted to cheating in the last year, compared with 47 per cent of non-business students. More than 5,000 MBA students from 11 graduate business schools in Canada and 21 schools in the U.S. took part.
Jim Fisher, vice-dean of MBA programs at University of Torontos Rotman
Senior executives give MBA courses mixed review
U.S. executives are generally positive about the way business schools prepare MBA graduates for the real world, according to a new survey -- but the approval is some way short of a grade A.
Overall, 69% of business executives felt MBA courses did a good job educating students to succeed in corporate life, said the study carried out for Graziadio School of Business and Management, part of Pepperdine University in Los Angeles.
However, only 7% rated the business schools job as excellent, and 21% marked them down as only fair.
More: edition.cnn.com
Survey finds MBA students most likely to cheat
When it comes to cheating in graduate school, a new study finds that MBA students are the champs.
A survey of 5,331 students at 32 graduate schools in the United States and Canada found an alarming amount of cheating across disciplines, but more among the nations future business leaders. Fifty-six percent of graduate business students admitted they had cheated at least once in the last year, compared with 47 percent of non-business students.
The students, who were surveyed between 2002 and 2004, told researchers from Pennsylvania State,
Prospective and current graduate business students who used a Web site to cheat on entrance examinations over the last five years could have their scores thrown out.
The exam's publisher, the Graduate Management Admission Council, is tracking down users of Scoretop.com after winning a lawsuit to shut down the site and seize a computer hard drive containing payment information and user identifications.
Scoretop sold VIP access for $30 a month, giving users previews to current questions on the latest Graduate Management Admission Test. Some were posted by users after taking the exam.
U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema also ordered site operator Lei Shi
Aaron F. Cooper II, a self-described worrywart, never thought his penchant for devising foolproof backup plans could translate into a calling. But that all changed when he signed up for an elective in risk management while at the University of Georgia's Terry School of Business executive MBA program last fall. "It entails pretty much everything I've always been interested in my entire life, even before I knew risk management existed," said Cooper, 27, a telecommunications engineer at AT&T (T).
Cooper is part of a new wave of students hitting business school campuses. For years, risk management—the process of analyzing exposure to
Giving in to pressure from academia and corporate guide, the Indian government has granted permission on the Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore to open a new campus in Singapore. The research activities and management Education Center's only IIMB campus of Southeast Asia.
If IIMB sought permission to open the facility in Singapore in November last year, officials of Human Resources Development Ministry said IIM law does not allow open offices overseas. Officer employee beyond the need to meet the needs at home. The conflict ended on Feb. 1, according to HRD and Minister Arjun Singh IIM directors met to consider changes,
IILM Part-Time Programs for Working Executives
Two Year Part-Time Post Graduate Diploma in Management (PGDM-EVE 2002-04)
One Year Part-Time Post Graduates Diploma in Insurance & Risk Management (PGDIRM-EVE-2002-03)
Academic Session Commences : September 23, 2002
Please write to : The Director
IILM : Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110 003
Source : Hindustan Times (New Delhi)
HYDERABAD: The Institute of Chartered Financial Analyst of India (ICFAI) University on Thursday announced the launch of two part-time courses - a 27-month Chartered Financial Analyst program and a three-year MBA program.
These programs, which is supported by the full-time faculty of the University of ICFAI, after 6 clock and is the same curriculum as the full-time courses.
A provision for an internship was also in the structures and, of course, certain changes to the benefit of working time executives, professionals and entrepreneurs in the content, ICFAI Dean Prof. CVA Prasada Rao, said addressing a press conference.
This is the first time that
If students cheat, before merit further examination, an Institute of marks, MCES's College of Education and Research in Mumbra reportedly spent with gusto. Instead, the college, which takes place in a full-time one-year study Bachelor of Education (beds) flunked of course, the test and said that the authorization to suspend for the academic year 1999-2000.
The penalty was proposed to require students to cheat on the criteria set by the University of Mumbai for its BEd, of course. Under the guise of "work" looks forward to all students in the cleanliness of the premises a day before an inspection, so that
IIMBs progress towards being an international B-school has been recognized through its inclusion in the Wall Street Journals list of top 100 business schools World Wide – the only B-school from India to be included in the list. IIMB has produced extremely successful leaders managing various businesses across Asia, USA and Europe.
For the first time in the history of India, Indian Institute of Management will be opening a campus outside India, in the form of a Research and Management Education Center in Singapore. The Singapore campus will be IIMBs only campus in South East Asia. This will be the 3rd
MBA Tag Clouds